Time off in lieu (TOIL) means giving someone paid time off instead of paying them for overtime they've worked. In the UK there's no legal right to it: the government's own guidance says the employer and employee agree the terms, such as when it can be taken, so your contract or written policy is what decides how it works.
That freedom is why TOIL causes so much trouble in small agencies. Nobody has to write anything down, so nobody does, and a year later there's a launch weekend from March that one person remembers as "owed" and the founder remembers as "a favour". This guide covers the UK rules that still apply, the Australian award rules (which are much stricter), the choices a TOIL policy has to make, and a policy you can copy.
What UK law says about TOIL
Very little directly, and quite a lot around the edges. The pieces that matter:
- Overtime pay isn't automatic. gov.uk says employers do not have to pay workers for overtime, and Acas says there is no automatic legal right to it. TOIL is one of the things an employer might offer instead.
- The written statement has to cover it. Acas says the written statement of employment particulars must state what hours count as overtime and what the rate of pay for overtime is. If your answer is "time off, not money", say so there or in a policy the statement points to.
- The minimum wage still applies. If someone works more hours than their contract says, their pay for the hours worked must not fall below the National Minimum Wage. From April 2026 that's £12.71 an hour for workers aged 21 and over, rising to £13.21 in April 2027.
- The 48-hour week still applies. Nobody can be made to work more than 48 hours a week on average, normally averaged over 17 weeks, unless they've opted out in writing. Overtime is only compulsory if the contract says so, and even then the 48-hour average holds (gov.uk, compulsory overtime).
- Part-timers aren't owed overtime rates until they pass full-time hours. Acas says part-time staff aren't entitled to overtime pay until they've worked more than the normal hours of full-time staff, unless your contract is more generous. They still mustn't be treated less favourably than full-timers.
So TOIL in the UK is a contract term. The law sets the floor (minimum wage, working time, fair treatment) and your policy fills in everything else.
Where the minimum wage catches agencies out
Most agency salaries sit comfortably above the minimum wage, until you divide them by the hours actually worked. A hypothetical junior designer:
| Contracted | What actually happened | |
|---|---|---|
| Salary | £26,000 | £26,000 |
| Hours a week | 37.5 | 41 on average across the year |
| Hours a year (52 weeks) | 1,950 | 2,132 |
| Pay per hour worked | £13.33 | £12.20 |
£12.20 is below the £12.71 minimum for someone aged 21 or over. Nobody decided to underpay this person. A few launch weeks, some pitch weekends and an evening or two a week did it, unrecorded and unpaid. HMRC's rules for working this out for salaried staff are more detailed than one division, so if anyone on your team is within a pound or two of the minimum, check the gov.uk minimum wage guidance or ask Acas. The practical point stands: when TOIL is actually taken, the hours come back down and the problem goes away. When it's "owed" and never taken, it doesn't.
TOIL and holiday pay
If you pay overtime regularly, it has to show up in holiday pay. Acas says holiday pay must include overtime payments if an employee has regularly received overtime pay during the previous year, for at least 4 of the 5.6 weeks for most employees. Time off in lieu sidesteps that, because the extra hours are repaid as time rather than money. If you pay some overtime and TOIL the rest, keep the two apart in your records.
TOIL in Australia: the award decides
Australia is the opposite of the UK. The Fair Work Ombudsman says some awards and registered agreements allow an employee to take paid time off instead of overtime pay, and those that do spell out exactly how.
Office and admin staff at many agencies fall under the Clerks—Private Sector Award 2020, so it's a useful example. Clause 23 says:
- Each lot of overtime needs its own written agreement, stating the hours and when they were worked. An exchange of emails counts.
- Time off is hour for hour: 2 hours of overtime gives 2 hours off.
- It must be taken within 6 months, at a time both sides agree.
- If it isn't taken in 6 months, or the employee asks for the money instead, or they leave, you pay it at the overtime rate that applied when it was worked.
- You keep a copy of each agreement as an employee record, and you must not pressure anyone into agreeing to TOIL.
Other awards have their own versions, and designers or developers may be covered by a different award or by none. Check which applies to each person before you write a policy for an Australian team.
Hour for hour, or time and a half?
UK employers can choose. The common options:
| Rate | 3 hours of weekend work earns | Fits |
|---|---|---|
| Hour for hour (1:1) | 3 hours off | Evening overruns, the odd late night |
| Time and a half (1.5:1) | 4.5 hours off | Weekends, early starts for a launch |
| Double (2:1) | 6 hours off | Bank holidays, emergency call-outs |
Most small agencies use 1:1 for everything, and some add 1.5:1 for weekends or bank holidays. Generous rates feel good, but every hour of TOIL is an hour that person isn't on client work later, so the rate is really a capacity decision. Australian awards like the Clerks Award fix it at hour for hour for TOIL.
What a TOIL policy has to decide
Nine decisions. Made once and written down, they're the difference between a rule people trust and a running argument about who's owed what.
- Who's eligible. Usually employees, not contractors. Senior people on higher salaries are often excluded because their pay already assumes some flexibility. Say so plainly rather than leaving it to guesswork, and remember the part-time rule above.
- What counts as overtime. Hours beyond contracted hours in a week, or beyond a day? Does an hour of travel to a client count? A clear line, such as "time beyond your contracted weekly hours, approved in advance", stops 20-minute overruns being banked.
- Approval before, not after. The single most useful rule. If extra hours need a manager's yes first, TOIL tracks real business need. Without it, TOIL becomes a reward for slow work, which is Parkinson's law with a leave balance attached.
- The rate. 1:1, or 1.5:1 for weekends and bank holidays.
- A cap. A ceiling on the balance, such as 3 days, stops someone building up two weeks that then lands on your busiest month.
- A deadline. "Use within 3 months" is common in the UK. It keeps the balance small and the hours honest.
- What happens to unused TOIL. Lost, paid out, or carried. If you say "lost", make sure the deadline was realistic and the person could actually take it. Repeatedly refusing requests and then letting time expire is the kind of thing that ends at a tribunal.
- Leaving. Paid out at the end, or must be taken during notice? Write it down. In Australia, the Clerks Award decides this for you: pay it.
- Booking it. TOIL is booked like annual leave, through the same request and approval, so it shows on the team calendar and doesn't collide with someone else's holiday.
A TOIL policy you can copy (UK)
Adapt the bracketed parts. Keep it next to your holiday policy and point to it from the written statement.
Time off in lieu (TOIL) policy
1. Who this covers
Employees on [contracted hours]. It does not cover contractors or
[roles excluded, e.g. directors].
2. What counts
Hours worked beyond your contracted weekly hours that your manager
approved before you worked them. Unapproved extra time doesn't earn TOIL.
3. How much you earn
One hour of TOIL for each extra hour worked. Hours worked on a weekend
or bank holiday earn [1.5] hours.
4. Recording it
Log the extra hours [in our time tracker / on the TOIL form] within
[5] working days. Your manager confirms them and they're added to your
TOIL balance.
5. Limits
Your TOIL balance can't go above [3] days. Take TOIL within [3] months
of earning it. TOIL not taken by then [is lost / is paid at your normal
hourly rate], unless we couldn't let you take it, in which case we'll
agree a new date.
6. Taking it
Book TOIL like annual leave, with the same notice. It can be taken in
half days [or hours].
7. Leaving
On leaving, unused TOIL is [paid at your normal hourly rate / to be
taken during your notice period].
8. Pay
We'll make sure your pay for all hours worked never falls below the
National Minimum Wage.
For Australian staff, don't use this as written. Start from the award clause or Schedule E agreement that covers each person.
Worked example: a launch month at a six-person agency
Hypothetical numbers, to show why the cap and the deadline matter. A six-person web agency has a site launch in March. Three people each work an extra 10 hours over two weeks, approved in advance, at 1:1, plus one Saturday of 6 hours at 1.5:1.
| Extra hours | TOIL earned | |
|---|---|---|
| Weekday overruns | 10 | 10 hours |
| Launch Saturday | 6 | 9 hours |
| Per person | 16 | 19 hours (about 2.5 days) |
| Three people | 48 | 57 hours (about 7.5 days) |
7.5 days of capacity comes off April. If April already has a retainer and a new project starting, those days need to be in the capacity plan now, not discovered when three TOIL requests arrive in the same week. And if the launch ran over because the estimate was wrong, the 48 hours are also the clearest signal you'll get that the next quote needs to be bigger. The 150% over estimate post walks through that.
Without a deadline, those 57 hours sit on a spreadsheet nobody checks. By autumn, two people have left and someone says they're owed four days.
How to track TOIL
TOIL is a balance that goes up when someone works approved extra hours and down when they take time off. That's the same shape as annual leave, so track it the same way: in the system people already use to book holiday.
In a spreadsheet, that means a TOIL column next to annual leave on each person's tab: date worked, hours, approved by, hours taken, balance. It works for a small team as long as one person keeps it up to date. The annual leave tracker layout has room for it.
In Suprwork, you'd add "Time off in lieu" as its own leave type in Time off, with an allowance of zero, a carry-over limit that matches your policy, and approval switched on. When extra hours are approved, an owner, admin or HR person adds them to that person's balance in half days, and has to give a reason, so the next person reading the balance can see where each half day came from. People then request TOIL like any other leave: working days and public holidays are counted, the balance is checked, and the right manager approves. It shows on the team calendar next to everyone else's holiday.
The extra hours themselves come from the time people log in Projects & Time, so you can check the claim against what was actually tracked on the project. Suprwork doesn't turn logged overtime into TOIL automatically and doesn't run payroll, so payouts at the end still go through your payroll provider. Keep the policy itself in Documents so it's in one place.
A dedicated HR tool or your payroll provider can do the same job, and if you already pay overtime through payroll, keeping TOIL there may be simpler.
A five-minute check on your current setup
- Is there a written TOIL policy, and does the written statement point to it?
- Does extra time need approval before it's worked?
- Is there a cap and a deadline?
- Can you see every person's TOIL balance today, in one place?
- Has anyone on a salary near the minimum wage worked long weeks this year?
- For anyone in Australia: do you know which award covers them, and do you have a written agreement for each lot of overtime?
If you answered no to two or more, start with the policy, then the tracking.
Sources
- gov.uk, Overtime: your rights and Time off and paid leave (checked 17 November 2026)
- gov.uk, Compulsory overtime and Maximum weekly working hours
- gov.uk, National Minimum Wage and National Living Wage rates
- Acas, Pay for working extra hours (last updated 28 March 2024)
- Fair Work Ombudsman, Overtime pay
- Fair Work Ombudsman, Clerks—Private Sector Award 2020, clause 23